5 Important Reasons Why Chickens Change Where They Lay Eggs
Finding eggs in a new spot can be confusing — especially if your hens have been using their nesting boxes reliably for months. One day everything is normal, and the next you’re discovering eggs on the coop floor, under the roost, or tucked into a corner.
In my experience, hens rarely change where they lay eggs “for no reason.” Egg-laying is a vulnerable moment, and when a hen chooses a different location, she’s usually responding to something about comfort, safety, routine, or how she’s feeling physically.
The key is learning how to read these changes calmly — not jumping to conclusions, but also not ignoring patterns when they appear.
1. Something About the Nesting Box Feels “Off”
Chickens are far more sensitive to their environment than we often realize. A nesting box that looks fine to us can feel completely different to a hen if even small details change.
This is especially common after a coop clean-out. While cleanliness is important, removing all familiar scent, changing bedding types, or leaving boxes brighter or draftier than usual can make a once-trusted nesting spot feel unfamiliar.
- • New or strongly scented bedding
- • Damp, compacted, or shallow nesting material
- • More light exposure than before
- • Air drafts or changes in ventilation
- • Increased foot traffic around the boxes
When this happens, hens often choose a spot that feels quieter or more secure — even if it’s not where you want them laying. Maintaining a consistent nesting routine helps reduce this kind of disruption.
2. Hens Are Following Another Hen’s Lead
Chickens are flock animals, and they pay close attention to what other hens are doing — especially when it comes to nesting. If one hen successfully lays eggs in a new location without being disturbed, other hens may decide that spot is acceptable too.
This is why a single floor egg can quickly turn into a pattern. Once a location becomes “approved” by the flock, it can take time and consistency to redirect everyone back to the nesting boxes.
Keeping all nesting boxes equally comfortable, familiar, and appealing helps prevent hens from establishing new group habits in less desirable spots.
3. Stress or Disruption in the Coop
Egg-laying is one of the most vulnerable moments for a hen. If something in the coop environment feels stressful or unpredictable, she may seek out a quieter or more hidden place to lay.
- • New flock members or pecking order changes
- • Predator activity nearby (even if no one is harmed)
- • Loud or unfamiliar noises
- • Changes to coop layout or access points
In these cases, changing laying locations is often a short-term response. Once the environment settles and routines return, many hens naturally go back to their usual nesting boxes.
4. Physical Discomfort or Laying Sensitivity
Sometimes a hen changes where she lays eggs because laying itself feels uncomfortable. She may hesitate, pace, try several locations, or choose a spot that requires less effort or pressure.
This doesn’t automatically mean something serious is wrong, but it is a reason to observe closely. When laying discomfort is the cause, you’ll often notice other subtle changes as well.
- • Repeated floor eggs from the same hen
- • Changes in posture or movement
- • Reduced appetite or energy
- • Spending more time alone
If nesting changes are paired with other behavior shifts, it’s a good idea to watch that hen more carefully. Early awareness makes intervention easier when it’s needed.
5. The Nesting Area No Longer Feels Private or Safe
Most hens prefer nesting areas that are dim, quiet, and predictable. If boxes become too busy, too bright, or frequently interrupted, a hen may decide another spot feels safer.
This can happen gradually — especially as flocks grow or routines change. What worked well before may no longer meet a hen’s need for privacy.
Small adjustments, like reducing traffic near nesting boxes or refreshing bedding consistently, often help restore a hen’s confidence in her nesting space.
When nesting boxes feel calm, familiar, and consistent, hens settle into predictable laying routines — and it becomes much easier to notice when something changes.
That’s why I rely on simple routines, including my Nesting Box Herbs, to help keep nesting areas inviting without overcomplicating things.
Nesting Box Herbs for Chickens
A fragrant blend of marigold, chamomile, peppermint, parsley, rosemary, fennel seed, dandelion, marjoram, and lavender to promote clean, inviting, stress-free nesting areas.
Shop Nesting Box Herbs
